A new study from Clutch is sounding an urgent alarm for marketers navigating a fast shifting landscape of customer expectations. As brands confront increasing skepticism, the research highlights a critical reality: consumer trust is deteriorating rapidly, and authenticity is now the defining factor in whether customers choose to support a brand. The report reveals that ninety seven percent of consumers say authenticity directly influences their purchasing decisions, underscoring how essential real connection has become in a market reshaped by automation and AI driven experiences.
The findings show how dramatically expectations have changed. Eighty five percent of respondents say they have purchased from a brand specifically because it felt authentic. Sixty two percent have recommended brands they consider genuine to others, and seventy percent are willing to pay more for companies they perceive as real. Jeanette Godreau, analyst at Clutch, emphasized the growing divide between brands that act authentically and those perceived as manufacturing the appearance of sincerity. “Consumers instantly recognize the difference between genuine behavior and surface level authenticity,” Godreau said. “In an AI heavy landscape, clarity, consistency, and real human presence are what build trust.”
Marketing Technology Insights: Phunware Announces Appointment of Elliot Han as Chairperson of the Board of Directors
The emotional weight consumers place on authenticity extends to how they evaluate brand signals. Transparency about processes and materials, which sixty nine percent identified as critical, topped the list. Unfiltered customer reviews and user generated content follow closely at sixty two percent, while fifty five percent cite a distinct brand voice as central to credibility. Forty two percent said visible human involvement influences whether they trust a brand, and forty one percent highlighted the importance of messaging consistency across channels. According to Godreau, authenticity is demonstrated not through slogans, but through a brand’s daily choices. “Authenticity is not a tagline. It is demonstrated through everyday behavior,” she said. “People define authentic brands by honest communication and actions that align with stated values.”
The risks are equally stark. The report shows that changes in product quality, noted by sixty one percent of respondents, are the fastest way to break consumer trust. Generic or robotic communication closely follows at fifty nine percent, reinforcing concerns that heavy AI usage risks erasing humanity from brand experiences. Mismatches between brand values and real world behavior ranked just behind at fifty six percent. More than half of respondents also said trend chasing signals a lack of identity. Eighty seven percent indicated they would stop supporting a brand entirely if its actions violated its stated values. As Godreau warned, “An inconsistent or performative brand experience is all it takes for trust to collapse. Consumers expect integrity, not perfection.”
Marketing Technology Insights: Linkhome Launches AI Advertising Platform and Pay for Closing Model
For marketers seeking guidance, the report stresses that resilience in an AI saturated environment will require transparency, human oversight, and consistency maintained over time. Brands that demonstrate a clear sense of purpose and back it with real actions can build loyalty even in competitive markets. As the study concludes, authenticity is emerging not just as a communication strategy, but as a measurable advantage that compounds with every customer interaction.
Marketing Technology Insights: Idomoo Partners With AWS To Power AI Video Creation on Amazon Q Business
For media inquiries, you can write to our MarTech Newsroom at info@intentamplify.com
