The Key to Marketing’s Future Is Buried in Brands Creative Past

Recent research has shown that 70% of marketing success comes from the creative the consumer sees – not just media impressions. Yet for years, the industry has obsessed over where ads run rather than what makes those impressions matter: the creative itself.

Creative is the single biggest driver of performance, but most marketers have unknowingly ceded ownership of their creative and its performance data to the platforms and partners.

We believe in a simple formula:

CREATIVE DATA + PERFORMANCE DATA = BRAND DNA

It sounds obvious, but years of insights are locked inside walled gardens. Unless brands reverse this flow, they risk losing their competitive advantage.

Recommended: The Hidden Cost of Signal Loss (And the Fix Marketers Need Now)

THE HIDDEN COST OF CREATIVE DATA LOSS

Platforms like Google, Meta, LinkedIn, TikTok, and Amazon excel at optimizing for their own ecosystems. The better the ROI looks inside their walls, the more money you spend.

But ROI that lives only within those walls is marketing’s equivalent of empty calories – quick hits that feel good but leave you hungry and dependent.

The bigger problem:

No technology today lets marketers holistically manage messaging across every channel. That responsibility still falls on the CMO. Even the most advanced AI can’t deliver results without a cross-channel system that organizes creative assets and performance data.

The costs are staggering. Gartner estimates 29% of marketing budgets are wasted due to duplication and fragmentation. McKinsey finds two-thirds of CMOs cite siloed data as their top barrier to agile, data-driven decision-making.

And fewer than half of marketers even measure creative effectiveness – only 1 in 10 use data to guide creative. Without a complete picture, brands risk repeating mistakes, burning budgets, and missing opportunities to scale what works.

Creative Data Sovereignty is a Strategic Imperative

Owning creative data, what we call Creative Data Sovereignty, is not just better reporting. It’s about reclaiming control to:

• Unlock the value of historical marketing assets – your brands’ DNA.
• Build your own intelligence layer instead of fueling someone else’s algorithm.
• Identify high-impact creative fast and shift budgets before waste compounds. Preserve institutional memory so insights survive turnover and agency changes.

As George Mathew of Insight Partners says: “The data substrate matters.” The taxonomy you control defines your ability to unlock the full value of AI. Without it, you’re flying blind.

Recommended: “Magical martech”: Personalization powered by AI

A Roadmap for Regaining Control

Marketers can take concrete steps now:

1. AUDIT: Map where creative assets and performance data live. Identify gaps and redundancies. Don’t wait for perfection – start.
2. ORGANIZE: Build a consistent taxonomy so assets are trackable across channels. Capture and categorize everything you create.
3. ELEVATE: Connect platforms into a unified environment where all assets and KPIs can be analyzed together. This becomes the historical record of your brand.

Most importantly, foster a Data-First Culture. Teams should use creative insights continuously, not only at campaign wrap-up. One marketing org spending seven figures a month told us they review all channels once a quarter. Let’s be honest – that’s a waste. Stop looking at what was. Look at what is to define what will be.

The Competitive Edge of Learning Faster

Brands that own and analyze creative and performance data in real time gain a compounding advantage. They make faster decisions, cut waste earlier, and spot growth opportunities others miss.

This isn’t just about efficiency – it’s about credibility. Marketers who control their data can answer the Board and C-suite fast. They shift from passively feeding platforms to actively owning insights.

Conclusion

The platforms know what works for your marketing…on their platform.

The question is: Do you?

Reclaiming creative data is not a technical upgrade; it’s a strategic imperative. Those who take control will build smarter campaigns, compound their learnings, and turn creative from a cost center into a durable competitive asset.

At mktg.ai, we’re building the foundational platform the marketing industry has been missing. The “Bloomberg Terminal” for creative intelligence. It unifies fragmented creative asset libraries and performance data into a single, structured system called the AI Marketing Model, giving marketers the foundation they need to fully harness the power of AI.

Recommended: Intent Data Value Investing: It’s Actually the Same Thing as What’s Needed for Growth